BLOG ⁇ Fragments

Liking a Trailer Is Not the Same as Liking a Film: Write a Thoughtful Review

Separately evaluate the film's experience with the promise of the trailer. Guide to preparing a movie grade without spoilers over fiction, sound, character, and scene examples.

Curtains and audience seats in the movie theater
Curtains and audience seats in the movie theater · Wolfmann / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Image source ↗ · Licence ↗

In a two-minute trailer, quick cuts, strong music, and selected dialogues can affect you. The film may not have the same rhythm in its entirety. This difference alone does not indicate that the film is bad; it shows that the experience offered by the work must be evaluated separately with the expectation that the introduction has established. The first thing to do when writing your own cinema note is to separate these two observations.

Read the trailer as a separate narrative

BFI's archive work, treats trailers as separate work recordings. This approach presents a good starting question: what does the short introduction you are watching promise you? Is it a thriller, a character journey, or a visual demonstration?

After watching the trailer, take only three brief notes: the genre I was waiting for, the narrative preference that caught my attention and the question that I was curious about. Do not write a definitive conclusion about acting or the script without seeing the film yet. The phrase 'Fragman created this expectation in me' is more honest than the sentence 'The movie is definitely like this'.

Store the first reaction after the movie is finished

I may have liked or bored your first note. Don't turn this into a final review right away. Think about what scene, rhythm or character decision the emotion is made of. Find an example that you can describe without spoilers; if you can't find it, assess whether your judgment is too general.

For example, instead of 'tempo slow', you could write a reasoned observation, such as 'parts repeating the same conflict delayed seeing a new decision of the character'. This sentence is not a claim about a particular film, but an original example of how the interpretation can be embodied.

Study the image and sound separately

BFI's writing on fiction, discusses the order and duration of selected images over examples in which it changes the relationship with the viewer. Do not compress fiction, sound, frame, and acting into a single 'beautiful' sentence in your own note.

Reconstruct a scene in your mind: was the information moved by image, dialogue, or music? Where did the camera or cutting choice draw your attention? Try to explain the effect of the preference, rather than memorizing individual technical names.

Make your own measure visible after all

Finish your grade with a brief main judgment, two concrete justifications, and a cautious assessment of which audience might find this experience interesting. Do not present your personal liking as a measure of quality that applies to everyone else. Do not use the sentences of another critic by changing a few words.

If you haven't seen the film, don't hide it; state that you're only doing a trailer evaluation. Good movie writing score is not saying it out loud, but explaining why you've come to that point or comment as clearly as the reader can argue.